Skip to main content

APO fratmen gets first taste of hazing law conviction - who's next?

APO fratmen gets first taste of hazing law conviction - who's next?


THE Anti-Hazing Law, or Republic Act 8049 gets to sink its teeth on real flesh for the first time, after the Supreme Court's conviction of two Alpha Phi Omega (APO) members for the hazing of University of the Philippines-Los Baños (UPLB) student Marlon Vilanueva in 2006.

This is the first conviction since the Anti-Hazing Law was passed on 1995, in the light of the death of Leni Villa, a law student from Ateneo de Manila who similarly died from hazing.

According to Inquirer.net, the high court's 39-page decision through Associate Justice Jose Catral Mendoza affirmed the penalty of reclusion perpetua (20 years and 1 day to 40 years imprisonment) imposed by the Calamba Laguna Regional Trial Court Branch 36 against Dandy L. Dungo and Gregorio A. Sibal Jr.

The Laguna RTC ruled that the prosecution has “undeniably proved” that the victim was seen with Dungo and Sibal entering a resort where the initiation rites were conducted and that the same two brought the victim to JP Rizal Hospital.

It added that while there was no evidence that Dungo and Sibal participated in the initiation rites, there were evidence that the two brought the victim to the venue where the final initiation rites were conducted and where the victim sustained injuries that led to his death.

The case went to the Court of Appeals who affirmed the lower court’s ruling thus it was elevated to the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court ruled:
“In the absence of direct evidence, the prosecution may resort to adducing circumstantial evidence to discharge its burden. Crimes are usually committed in secret and under conditions where concealment is highly probable. If direct evidence is insisted on under all circumstances, the prosecution of vicious felons who commit heinous crimes in secret or secluded places will be hard, if not impossible to prove,”  
“The unbroken chain of events laid down leaves us no other conclusion other than the petitioners’ participation in the hazing…With the fact of hazing, the identity of the petitioners and their participation therein duly proves, the moral certainty that produces conviction in an unprejudiced mind has been satisfied,” 


Hazing deaths history in the Philippines

In an article from Philstar on July 2014, it listed about 22 hazing deaths in the country since the year 2000, as follows:

2014: Guillo Servando — An 18-year-old Benilde sophomore believed to have suffered severe beating and died following initiation rites under the Tau Gamma fraternity.

2013: John Mark Dugan — A 19-year-old sophomore marine cadet in the Maritime Academy of Asia and the Pacific whose death was linked to hazing.

2012: Marc Andre Marcos — A 20-year-old San Beda University law student who was allegedly beaten to death by members of Lex Leonum fraternity. The accused were cleared from charges in 2013.

Marvin Reglos — A 25-year-old San Beda law student was reportedly killed during hazing rites held by the Lambda Rho Beta fraternity in Antipolo City.

2011: E.J. Karl Intia — A University of Makati student believed to have aspired to join the Alpha Phi Omega fraternity but ended being killed in initiation rites. His body was recovered near a 30-foot cliff in Laguna.

2010: Noel Borja Jr. — A 15-year-old elementary student and neophyte who reportedly was assaulted to death by members of Tau Gamma Phi fraternity. The brotherhood learned that Borja's parents belong to rival Alpha Kappa Rho fraternity.

2009: Glacy Monique Dimaranan — A 15-year-old girl who died of a single gunshot wound in the head during initiation rites. A member of Scout Royal Brotherhood in Laguna accidentally pulled the trigger of the gun he was pointing at the victim.

John Daniel Samparanda — An 18-year-old  Lyceum of the Philippines student in General Trias, Cavite believed to have died in Tau Gamma Phi fraternity rites.

Elvin Sinaluan — A 21-year-old Scout Royal Brotherhood entrant whose life was reportedly ended in brutal admission rites. Sinaluan and fellow victims "were hit by paddle every 30 seconds for two hours," authorities said.

Karl Anthony Gaudicos — A 18-year-old engineering student of the Holy Cross of Davao College who died in hazing activities under the Tau Gamma Phi and Tau Gamma Sigma.

2007: Cris Anthony Mendez — A 20-year-old University of the Philippines student and allegedly a Sigma Rho fraternity neophyte died of mauling during initiation rites.

Jan Angelo Dollete — A 21-year-old engineering student suspected to be killed in Sapian, Capiz by members of the Alpha Phi Omega.

2006: Clark Anson Silverio — A Technological University of the Philippines mechanical engineering student was dead upon arrival at the Manila Sanitarium Hospital in Pasay City after cruel initiation rites believed to be by Tau Gamma Phi fraternity.

Marlon Villanueva — A 21-year-old agriculture economics from the University of the Philippines Los Baños died in fraternity rites held in a resort in Calamba, Laguna.

Dan Robert Talibutab — A criminology student from St. Therese College in Iloilo was believed to be a victim of hazing by members of the non-accredited school organization Kapatiran ng Kabataan sa Kriminolohiya.

2004: Mark Welson Chua — The University of Santo Tomas student exposed corruption among Reserve Officers' Training Corps officials was killed by fellow student. Defendants during trial claimed that Chua died in fraternity hazing rites.

2003: Emerson Berry Jr. — A 16-year-old fourth year student from the Casanayan National High School was beaten up and died in initiation rites by members of the Beta Sigma Rho brotherhood in Pilar, Capiz.

2001: Rafael Root Albano III — The aspiring doctor was believed to be killed by members of the Sigma Mu fraternity of medicine students based in the Far Eastern University Laguna campus.

Fernando Balidoy — An 18-year-old probationary midshipman died as he was undergoing initiation conducted by upperclassmen of the Philippine Merchant Marine Academy.

Monico de Guzman — A Philippine Military Academy plebe whose death was attributed to illness by academy officials. His father, however, believes Monico Jr died of the notorious "beat attack" against entrants in boot camp.

Edward Domingo — The 23-year-old Camiling, Tarlac native and Philippine Military cadet reportedly died of cardio-respiratory attack due to injuries he suffered from hard blows to the lower part of the rib cage. Two cadets were convicted for homicide.

2000: Ace Bernabe Ekid — The 21-year-old was said to have died from stroke due to rigorous training exercises at the Philippine Military Academy. His family and friends, however, insisted Ace was a victim of hazing and foul play.


WHAT DO YOU THINK OF THIS POST?
Share your ideas by commenting.

Comments

Popular Posts

What to do when you get a HIT on your NBI clearance

A "Hit" on your NBI clearance after your long queue at the NBI satellite office. UPDATED January 2020 Department of Justice (DOJ) Circular 017, or the multi-purpose clearance does  away with the usual separate applications for domestic employment, travel abroad, gun licensing and many others, thereby making it easier for people to obtain and use an NBI clearance. Are you applying for your NBI clearance? The National Bureau of Investigation office has stopped entertaining walk-ins after the implementation of the fully online application process for NBI clearance. The registration and appointment system for the NBI clearance are done online nationwide. Applicants may accomplish the application form at www.doj.gov.ph/nbi , www.nbi.gov.ph , and clearance.nbi.gov.ph . READ: Complete Guide To nCoV: How Not To Misinform Yourself About The Coronapocalypse After registering online, applicants may proceed to any of the NBI sites nationwide for the payment and biom...

ShopeeVIP+ adds YouTube Premium Lite in Indonesia, Thailand, and the Philippines

Following the momentum of ShopeeVIP+, Shopee has announced its newest addition to the “Shopping meets Streaming with One subscription, more ways to stream!” offering: YouTube Premium Lite. Starting 11 November, ShopeeVIP+ subscribers in Indonesia, Thailand and the Philippines will have access to both YouTube Premium Lite and Netflix, with no additional fee beyond the ShopeeVIP+ subscription fee. With YouTube Premium Lite, ShopeeVIP+ subscribers can: Watch their favourite videos with fewer ads Download most videos to watch later, even without mobile data or Wi-Fi. Keep most videos playing in the background while using other apps or when the screen is locked Existing ShopeeVIP+ members can activate YouTube Premium Lite in the Shopee app or through the activation link sent via e-mail or SMS from 11 November at no additional cost. This latest addition strengthens the value of ShopeeVIP+ for Filipinos. Bey...

Hello, Vietnam! Vietjet launches three new direct services for travelers from Cebu and Clark

New direct flights now available: Cebu – Hanoi, Cebu – Ho Chi Minh City and Clark – Ho Chi Minh City, fares from just USD75/one-way Ready for your next adventure? Vietjet has officially launched three new round-trip routes from Cebu and Clark to Ho Chi Minh City and Hanoi. More Filipinos will have access to Vietnam’s most iconic cultural hubs. The launch ceremonies were held at Mactan-Cebu International Airport and Clark International Airport on November 10, welcoming the new services with celebrations attended by representatives of Mactan Cebu International Airport Authority (MCIAA); Cebu Provincial Government; Lapu-Lapu City Government; Department of Transportation (DOTr); Department of Tourism Central Visayas and Region III; Civil Aviation Authority of the Philippines; Aboitiz InfraCapital Cebu Airport Corporation; Luzon International Premiere Airport Development (LIPAD) Corp; Bases Conversion and Development Authority (BCDA), business p...

What the LTO says about changing mag wheels, rims and tires of your car, motorcycle

The new LTO PMVIC, or the Land Transportation Office - Private Motor Vehicle Inspection Centers, has started operations in some parts of the country for inspections of cars and motorcycles due for registration renewal. Dubbed as MVIS (Motor Vehicle Inspection System), it aims to test the roadworthiness of private and commercial vehicles prior to their registration. This also includes the checking of modifications, upgrades and accessories that have been installed on your vehicles - whether factory or aftermarket. If they don't meet LTO standards, you fail the test. Failing the MVIS test means you have to retake the inspection and worse, you can't register your vehicle any more. For purposes of discussion, I chose to talk about wheels and tires because they are the most frequently modified parts of our cars and motorcycles. Now comes the question: Is it considered illegal to replace your wheels with aftermarket mag wheels? Can those u...

Get the All-New HONOR Play 20A, Pad X7b with exclusive deals online

HONOR Philippines is giving shoppers more ways to enjoy its latest devices through exclusive deals on Shopee and TikTok Shop as part of the 11.11 shopping season. The HONOR Play 20A is available exclusively on Shopee, while the HONOR Pad X7b can be purchased through HONOR's official TikTok Shop. The HONOR Play 20A is available exclusively on Shopee for PHP 8,099, down from its PHP 8,999 SRP, with additional vouchers, free shipping on qualified purchases, and flexible payment options through SPayLater. It features a 2-inch Smart Rear Screen that lets users check notifications, control media, and take selfies using the rear camera, alongside a 6.9-inch 90Hz display and a 6,000mAh battery for everyday entertainment and use. For tablet users, the HONOR Pad X7b is available exclusively on TikTok Shop for PHP 8,999, down from its PHP 10,999 SRP, as part of its early-bird offer running until November 13. Customers can also enjoy flexible payme...

Your Complete Commuters' Guide to UV Express/FX Terminals in Metro Manila

UPDATED January, 2020 Metro Manila’s hordes of workers pour in by UV Express. Times are a-changing. With the increasing temperature in the metropolis coupled by its worsening traffic condition , a newer, more convenient alternative of transporting people had risen above all else. They're called the commuter vans, or what are now popularly known as the Utility Vehicle (UV) Express and FX vans. READ: Complete Guide To nCoV: How Not To Misinform Yourself About The Coronapocalypse UV Express vans are all air conditioned, seat an average of 14 passengers and charge relatively cheap compared to the usual metered taxicabs. Their fares range from as low as P20 to as high as P50 per passenger. With the LTFRB (Land Transportation Franchising and Regulatory Board) serving as regulator of the UV Express franchise, the commuter vans has increased its service routes exponentially all around the country, including Metro Manila. READ: My Epically Awesome Traffic Jam Day In...

Anko expands Philippine footprint to nine stores, enters Laguna and Cavite

Australian home and lifestyle brand Anko is accelerating its long-term growth in the Philippines, expanding its retail footprint from six to nine stores across key economic and residential districts before the end of 2026. The expansion marks a major milestone in Anko’s local journey, taking the brand beyond Metro Manila for the first time since its Philippine debut in November 2024. The brand will enter the rapidly growing Southern Luzon corridor with upcoming store openings at Ayala Malls Nuvali in Laguna on November 12 and Ayala Malls Evo City in Cavite on November 27, while simultaneously deepening its urban presence at Festival Mall in Muntinlupa on December 10. The three stores will span 1,573.11 square meters, 1,261.20 square meters, and 1,530.29 square meters, respectively. The strategic move into Laguna and Cavite places Anko directly inside CALABARZON, one of the country’s most dynamic growth hubs. By anchoring in master-planned ...

How much is the penalty for 5 years late registration of motorcycles?

UPDATED December, 2020 Got late in your motorcycle registration renewal? Driving an unregistered motor vehicle carries with it a fine of P3,000 if apprehended by Metropolitan Manila Development Authority (MMDA) officers and P10,000 if by LTO traffic personnel. Worse, if the non-registration exceeded one month, the vehicle will be impounded and released only once the vehicle has been registered and the corresponding fines and penalties have been paid. To help you prepare for your visit at the LTO, here's a brief guide on how much money you're going to spend on your motorcycle registration renewal. READ: Complete Guide To nCoV: How Not To Misinform Yourself About The Coronapocalypse What's covered in this guide? 1. LTO penalty formula by weeks 2. Sample computation (if 5 years late) 3. How to renew your motorcycle registration  - Requirements  - 5 step guide YOU MAY WANT TO WATCH:  Motorcycle Transfer of Ownership and Renewal of Registration ...

vivo V80 now available nationwide, Shopee deals until Nov 25

Customers who pre-ordered the vivo V80 can now claim their devices as the latest smartphone from vivo becomes available in stores nationwide. Those who placed their pre-orders at physical stores may visit their respective stores to claim their units, while customers who ordered through the vivo e-store or vivo Store app can complete their payment and have their devices delivered directly to their doorsteps. For those who have yet to get their hands on the vivo V80, the smartphone has also launched exclusively on Shopee, where shoppers can enjoy special deals and payment options until November 25. The offers include monthly installments starting at Php 3,120, 0% interest for up to 12 months, Shopee vouchers worth up to Php 2,000 off, and an additional 8% discount using the vivo voucher. The vivo V80 also emerged as the No. 1 best-selling smartphone in the Php 40,000 to Php 50,000 price ...

GCash Turns 20: 20 Features in 20 Years

From Bills to Budget Goals: Top 20 GCash Features that Make Finances a Breeze What started as a simple SMS money transfer has exploded into the financial super app that Filipinos can’t live without! For 20 years, GCash has been rolling out feature after feature, making life easier, faster, and more inclusive for everyone. From sending money in seconds to paying bills, shopping, and even investing, GCash has completely transformed how we handle money. And guess what? These 20 game-changing features are just a taste of what GCash has to offer! There’s a whole world of services in the app waiting to be explored. Ready to dive into some of the crowd favorites? Let’s begin! 1. SMS Money Transfer This is where it all began! Picture this: it’s 2004, flip phones are the hottest gadgets, and texting is the way to stay connected. Then GCash swoops in and changes the game, letting people send and receive money with a simple SMS/text! GCash...